Esteemed Shia Scholar exposes the bitter truth about the 12th Imam.


In The Name of Allah, The Beneficent, The Merciful.

In our previous articles, we set forth some very important and crucial questions for Shias regarding the “GUIDANCE” of their 12th Imam, as CHALLENGE. For a long period no Shia dared to answer those questions, but eventually we found some Shias taking up that Challenge but unfortunately they, miserably failed to answer those questions{their answers can be read over here [Click Here]}.

Praise be to Allah! Now we have found answers to the crucial and very important questions which we have set forth as a “Challenge” to Shias, from the book of a renowned and highly respected Shias scholar. This esteemed Shia scholar have exposed the Shia “illusion and myth” about the guidance of their 12th Imam, which is a very harsh and bitter truth for Shias. But we would like to remind our respected Shia readers that, its the nature of truth, So please ponder over the answer of this esteemed Shia scholar and think over this issue in a rational and open minded way. May Allah guide all the truth seeking Shias. Ameen.

One of the biggest Shia scholars of our times refutes the Shia myth regarding the guidance of 12th Imam. 

Shia scholar Muhammad Asif Muhsini said in his book “Mashra`at Bihar al-Anwar”, volume 1 page 408:

الغيبة التي امتدت أكثر من ألف سنة وربما تمتد إلى آلاف أو ملايين السنين. فإن المؤمنين لم ينتفعوا ولا ينتفعون من إمامهم الغائب – عجل الله تعالى فرجه – في الأصول والفروع ، وما يقال بخلاف ذلك فهو تخيل وتوهم ولعب بالعقول
[This Ghaybah that has taken more than a thousand years and maybe it shall keep going for thousands or millions of years. The believers living in it did not and do not benefit from their hidden Imam(may Allah hasten his appearance) in Usool or Furu`, and all else which is said is nothing but illusions and imaginations and playing with people’s minds.]

Muhammad Asif Muhsini said in the same book volume 2 page 223:

ولا يمكن القول بانتفاعنا منه عليه السلام في زمن الغيبة في الأمور الدينية إلا ممن سلب الله عقله
[It is not possible for us to say that we benefit from him (peace be upon him) in religious matters during his Ghaybah, except those whom Allah has robbed them of intellect.]

Finally Muhammad Asif Muhsini said in footnote #1, in volume 1 page 82:

وأي فائدة لهذه الأحكام المخزونة عند الأئمة: والمكلفون يحرمون منها في أكثر من ألف سنة ولعله في ألف مليون سنة
[And what benefit does this knowledge stored with Imams hold: when the Mukallafoun(Shia) are deprived from it for more than a thousand years, and maybe it’ll last for a billion years.]

Praise be to Allah! Thus what Ahlesunnah is claiming from centuries and for which Shia scholars had no rational reply, we found that an honest and esteemed Shia scholar admitted that the claims of Ahlesunnah are 100% correct. Now the Shia brothers and Sisters should open their eyes, where they will find that their illusion and myth have been refuted by their own scholar.

Now to give this bitter fact a twist let us present before our readers one of the boldest claim of Shiawebsite, where they declared that Prophet Muhammad(Saw) is not their Guide.

Here we find the bold claim of Shias that Prophet Muhammad(saw) is NOT a GUIDE to people after his death.(Mazallah). Ironically, Shia scholar Muhammad Asif Muhsini declared that 12th Imam is not benefiting(guiding) the Shias. So now we have a Shia claim, that Prophet Muhammad(Saw) is NOT their GUIDE, hence He is not guiding them, and on the other hand we have Shia scholar who says that their 12th Imam is not guiding them. So would like the Shias to ponder that, who is guiding them?

If Shias say that, they are being guided from the teachings and sunnah of their Imams who came before the present 12th Imam. Then what is the need of the guides after Prophet(Saw), Because Prophet(saw) is the primary source of Islamic teachings and Sunnah, and when these are the things through which we can attain guidance, So what is the need of the guides after Prophet Muhammad(Saw), when his teaching and Sunnah can guide us? Because Ahlesunnah are being guided by Prophet Muhammad(Saw) till date, through his teachings and Sunnah. So why don’t you seek guidance from the best man who walked on earth, and upon whom Allah completed his religion and called him as the best example for believers.

Lastly, We request  our respected Shia readers to ponder over these questions. May Allah guide all truth-seeking Shias and May Allah grant them Hidayah.

It is not for any person to believe, except by the leave of Allah, and He will put the Rijs(doubt) on those who do not reason. Quran (10:100)

May Allah send Salah and Salam on the Prophet(saw), his household, companions and those who follow them.

One thought on “Esteemed Shia Scholar exposes the bitter truth about the 12th Imam.

  1. In the book “Akaid al-Imamiya” shia shaykh Muhammad Reda Muzaffar said:

    We believe that, just as it is necessary for Allah to send someone as a prophet, so it is also necessary for Him to appoint an Imam. It is necessary that at all times there should be an Imam to represent the prophet, and that he should perform the duties of the prophet, such as guiding the people, and showing them the way of goodness and prosperity in this world and the next. He ought also to hold the highest position as a public authority in all aspects of people’s lives, so that he may cause Justice to increase among them and eliminate enmity and oppression from between them. The Imamate is therefore a continuation of the prophethood, and the reasoning which proves the former’s necessity is the same as that which proves the latter’s.

    So presence and availability of Imam is necessity in shia faith. He should judge between peoples, establish justice, help oppressed, and punish oppressors. You see the question?

    Shaykh of shias, allama Baqir Sharif al-Qurashi in his book “The life of Imam al-Mahdi” said: The major occultation began after the death of Ali bin Muhammad Samari in 328 A.H.

    Now is already 1431 year by hijra. Obviously 12-th imam DIDN’T judged between people, DIDN’T help oppressed, DIDN’T punish oppressors during 1103 years!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s